Sunny Garden Review of Sakura's Senshi Circle - 2004
Part One: SilverRunningWater89's Review
Originality- 19/20: First of all, this is probably the highest I've given so far! ^_~ At first, I didn't really see anything that really got my attention. (Your splash page was beautifully done... nicely organized and great on the eyes). But then I browsed around, it's great that you have a lot of different things to do. Fanfics, contests, midi's.... You did a really great job having a variety of things to do! (By the way, your fanfic is good!) The only thing that I took off for is not having something original to your site. Something that people can remember your site for... but other than that, it was perfect and I enjoyed looking around!Layout- 15/15: Beautifully done! I've already told you how nice your splash page was... but the actually layout itself was very nice. It was organized, easy on the eyes, navigation was fine, I was able to find everything, everything matched! The only thing that I'd advise is that maybe you have some type of border separating the page from the navagation. It was easy to see the writing and everything was very clear.
Content- 20/20: I've already said that you have a lot of things to keep the reader busy. A little bit for everyone, just maybe have something that's original to your site. I would probably come back, you did a nice job trying to keep everyone happy.
Info- 15/15: No questions asked here! Everything was clarified, easy to locate, and understandable. You even gave away spoilers ^_~. Even though you didn't give the history of SM, at least you redirected browsers to a page where they might find it if they wanted it. Very commendable.
Loading Time- 9/10: Everything loaded fine. Pictures took a little bit longer, but didn't take so long that I started having slower metabolism.;-D
Effort- 19/20: It certainly looked as though it took you a long time to make the site. It was very well done, although a bit plain, I can see HTML being used. Nothing was extravagantly used in a horrifying way. It was fun to look around. Nicely done. (Although on your splash page it says something like minimize pop ad for sanity??? What did that mean? I was thoroughly confused because a freakin' pop up ad kept on popping up when ever I went to a new page!!! But that's not your fault. I would suggest either clarifying it or removing it.
Total- 97/100: A! (The very first one I gave out!)
Part Two: Mystical Angel's Review
Orginality: 20/20 Wow this is an awesome site! Very interactive! I have no suggestions here. It is perfect!Layout: 13/15 Your layout is beautiful! I love it! Very organized, easy on the eyes, easy to navigate. Your splash page was my favorite. Although, on your main pages, it is a little plain. Maybe add a pink side border that seperates your links from your page. I think you can do a little more besides a title picture.
Content: 20/20 I was not bored at all here! Your visitors are probably kept busy for hours, and best of all, they probably come back! I don't think I could handle this many things on one site.
Info: 15/15 Everything was said when needed to be said. I was not confused in any way. Not only did I have a wonderful understanding of Sailor Moon from your summaries, but your directions and explaination of things was very well done.
Loading Time: 8/10 I did have a bit of trouble with loading every once in a while. Mainly I had trouble with opening pages. I don't know if it my computer, or maybe you have to busy of pages, meaning slow down on all the things you put up.
Effort: 20/20 I think you love this site, and it shows very much. Nothing this great did not go without time, dedication, and a love for the Sailor Moon series. I'm sure many people out there admire you very much. Keep up the great work! :)
Overall: 96% A
Return to Awards Page